Providing program interface not money transmission

Download official copy (PDF) 

March 25, 2019

Re:       _______________

Dear _______________:

Thank you for your letters dated October 8, 2018 and February 4, 2019, regarding the proposed activities of ____________________ (“__________”).  Your colleague, ____________________, also supplemented your request in her email dated February 21. In your correspondence, you ask whether ____________________’s proposed activities would require a money transmitter license in California.

In your correspondence you explained that ____________________ will offer various services through a digital platform and through its kiosks.  On the digital platform, a customer will be able to use the Dash Application to make peer-to-peer transfers of the cryptocurrency Dash, and purchase or sell Dash to a third-party exchanger. Additionally, customers will be able to use “Merchant Tools” to facilitate purchases paid for with Dash. At its physical kiosks, customers will be able to purchase or sell Dash in exchange for U.S. dollars directly from ____________________.

You and your colleague confirmed that ____________________ will not receive fiat currency for the purpose of transmission in carrying out any of these services. For purchases and sales of Dash on the digital platform, ____________________ does not take custody or control of a customer’s fiat currency, and is not liable for the transfer of fiat currency during that purchase/sale. Instead the customer’s fiat currency is transferred between the customer’s third-party financial institution account and a third-party exchanger (the customer is a direct client of each). ____________________ is not a party to the transaction between those third parties and is not liable for the customer’s fiat currency. Rather, ____________________’s only role in this transaction is providing the application program interface via the Dash Application, which enables the customer to conduct the transaction from a single interface.  

For the Merchant Tools service, customers can initiate a purchase for which they intend to pay with Dash using the Merchant Tool system. ____________________ receives the transaction directions and submits the request to two parties: _______________ to confirm there is sufficient Dash in the customer’s wallet; and the Custodian, to obtain the Dash wallet addresses for each of the merchant and ____________________. ____________________ then generates a QR code for a proxy payment that will allow the customer to authorize the transfer of Dash to the proxy payment address, at which point the Dash will be transferred from the customer’s Dash wallet to the merchant’s Dash wallet, with commission fees in Dash being transferred to ____________________’s Dash wallet. During these transactions, ____________________ only provides the application program interface to facilitate the integration between the various parties involved. In this type of transaction, there is no fiat currency involved. Merchants can also use the Merchant Tool to sell Dash in exchange for U.S. dollars.

Because ____________________ is never receiving fiat currency for the purpose of transmission in performing the above-described activities, and is never liable for the transmission of a customer’s fiat currency, these activities are not subject to the requirements of the Money Transmission Act. The Department’s determination is limited to the activities described herein and does not extend to any other activities in which ____________________ may engage.

This opinion is based solely on the facts presented in your correspondence, and the Department’s understanding of those representations. The Department may reach a different conclusion under other facts and circumstances. 

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at __________________________.

 

Sincerely,

 

Jan Lynn Owen

Commissioner

Department of Business Oversight

 

By

 

 

__________________________

Senior Counsel

 

 

Last updated: Nov 5, 2019 @ 2:03 pm